Skip to content

Essays

22 essays, five arguments, one subject: why the homes that let an ordinary household own are the hardest homes in America to buy.

I write these to be argued with. Each one makes a claim specific enough to check, about a rule, a form or a number, and says where the evidence comes from.

They share a premise. A middle-class family builds wealth by owning the home it lives in, and for a century one of the surest ways in was a home with a second unit that paid rent. The country stopped selling that home to the people it was built for. I think most of the reasons are plumbing, and plumbing can be fixed.

If you work in mortgages, appraisal, building or policy and you think I have something wrong, tell me. That is what these are for.

Write to meLinkedIn

New here? Start with How a home that generates rent while you live there builds generational wealth: the whole case on one page, with the government's own data.

Argument 1

The duplex is the real starter home.

A home with a second unit can be easier to qualify for than a cheaper house, because the lender counts the rent. Almost no buyer is told.

The “starter home” has become a financial contradiction: something too expensive to start with.

From Is the Duplex the New Starter Home?

Argument 2

We had housing that worked, and we abandoned it.

Two-flats and triple-deckers housed working families a century ago, and the mortgage rules that financed them were never repealed. What disappeared was everything around the rules.

They emerged for a simple reason: a single working-class wage couldn’t cover a mortgage, but two or three partially occupied units could.

From We Had Housing That Worked

Argument 3

The mortgage machine prefers to say no.

The loan exists. The file is harder to build, an error in it can be punished years later, and nobody inside a lender is paid for the extra work.

The same rent stream is real cash flow when an investor owns the property and unreliable income when an owner-occupant owns it.

From The Missing Middle Financing Failure

Argument 4

These homes are shown to the wrong buyer.

Listed as investments and judged on rent, they sit. The household that could pay more for one rarely sees the listing, and the listing never says what it would cost to live there.

The property sits: legal, rentable, financeable, and unnoticed.

From The Building That Doesn’t Know What It Is

Argument 5

Builders and policymakers are modelling the wrong person.

Small homes pencil when the buyer is the household that lives there. Most pro formas, and most housing politics, assume it is a landlord.

The answer is 100 people building one unit each.

From The Housing Debate is Missing a Player